AMAZING food, huge portions and the cost is really low. I've had pizzas, pastas, calzones, salads, dessert. All had great flavor and were cooked perfectly. I ordered through GrubHub one day and ILNYP responded so efficiently that the food was actually still a little too hot to eat when I received it on the other side of town. The folks who work here are really nice and will help you if you have any questions. They are not in-your-face in their care of their customers, which I really like. If I want help I'll ask. My family and I will be coming back a lot.

I got my pizza to go and it was the best decision! Not because the atmosphere was lacking, quite the opposite, they were playing great music and the vibe was so chill. I am happy I left because the way I ate those slices, I might have embarrassed myself. Lol Roma Pizza add Jalapenos!! All I have to say!! I will be back!!!

I recently tried I Love NY Pizza, and it was absolutely amazing! The pizza was fresh out of the oven with a perfectly crispy crust, gooey cheese, and the most delicious toppings. Each bite was a flavor explosion, and it honestly made me feel like I was in New York. The combination of fresh ingredients and expert preparation really made this pizza stand out. I couldn’t stop eating, it was that yummy! Highly recommend to anyone looking for a truly satisfying pizza experience!

I'm always skeptical about places that claim to have NY Pizza. I grew up in Brooklyn and in FL everyone claims to have NY Pizza but it's usually not very good. When I arrived, I was a bit worried because although I'm a "brown dude", I was surprised to see "brown folks" running a pizza spot. It smelled and looked great so I just grabbed the food and left. I brought the Pizza back to the hotel...and man...it was delicious! The crust was thick but the bottom was still nice and crunchy. The sauce was also delicious and it had good cheese. We ate every last piece, crust and all. When I'm in Gainesville again, I'll most definitely make the stop again...a few times.

Cousins service was great, the lady at the from was polite and friendly, I ordered the steak Stromboli and it was “Hot and flavorful”. I definitely recommend to come here.

This shop is located in a strip mall. This was my first time here and I had a good experience. I called ahead and placed my order (I even was able to add to it when I realized I wanted more items). Upon arrival my order was ready and I choose some drinks from their fridge. I highly recommend the garlic knots I loved them. There is also inside and outside seating, where they will bring the food to you once you place your order.

I’m originally from NY and the pizza was delicious but not some of the staff and owners that worked here.

We ordered delivery a few weeks ago at work. We ordered over the phone and the service was great. The pizza was a huge hit and disappeared quickly. Highly recommend the pepperoni rolls and the Roma pizza!! We will definitely order from here again